Grade A Bullshit is a witty and thought-provoking documentary that asks a deceptively simple question: Who decides a climbing grade? After adaptive climber Maureen Beck finally achieves her long-sought first 5.12 route, the celebration is short lived when the climb is downgraded. The experience leaves her wondering whether grades are objective measures of difficulty, or reflections of ego, bias, and the culture surrounding climbing. Determined to find answers, Maureen sets her sights on Far From God, a notoriously difficult Kentucky testpiece. As she battles the route, the film expands beyond one climber’s pursuit into a broader exploration of climbing’s endless grade debates. Through humor, sharp conversations, and a cast of outspoken voices, Grade A Bullsh*t examines how numbers shape identity, fuel online arguments, and influence who gets recognized, believed, or dismissed. Equal parts comedy and social commentary, the film invites audiences to question the systems we create to measure achievement. Because in climbing, as in life, the hardest thing to define may not be the climb itself, but the value we attach to it. Are grades real? Or are they Grade A Bullshit?
